Do Beginners Need a Heart Rate Monitor?

"I have a watch that monitors my heart rate. Is it necessary to monitor my heart rate while doing the beginners running program #3? You mentioned on your site running at easy pace. I assume I would need to figure out for myself what that is and then use my heart rate monitor? You also mentioned on your site how to find your max. heart rate (and then finding my different zones like easy pace) - I'm not so sure I want to run fast for .8km, rest for 30 - 45 seconds, and then run full out for another .8km. I don't know if I could at this point! Any other suggestions that would be accurate? Today I did the "walk 1 minute/run 4 minutes - 5x". It was a bit of challenge and I felt I had to push myself some. Is this normal, or should it feel easier?"

– Kathryn, Canada

Answer by Dom:
Hi Kathryn, Thanks for your question and happy to hear you are one of many starting out with Beginners Running Program 3. No: you don't need a heart rate monitor to get through a walk-run program. Running at a conversational effort, the talk test, is a more reliable guide than a heart rate zone calculated from a guessed maximum. A monitor earns its keep later, once you've got an accurate max heart rate and a reason to train by zone.

My below answer provides you with more context:
  1. Why "Run by Feel" Beats a Guessed Heart Rate Zone
  2. How to Use the Talk Test in a Run-Walk Session
  3. When It's Worth Adding a Heart Rate Monitor
  4. How to Find Your Real Max Heart Rate When You're Ready
  5. Is It Normal for a Run-Walk Session to Feel Hard?

Why "Run by Feel" Beats a Guessed Heart Rate Zone

Runner in dark top and cap on a dirt path toward a torii gate among misty trees, seen through a chain-link fence.
The classic formula for working out your maximum heart rate is 220 minus your age. It's popular because it's simple. It's also a population average, not a measurement of you specifically. Commonly off by 10 beats per minute (bpm) or more, in either direction, for any individual.

Take a 40-year-old. The formula says 180. Their real maximum could easily sit anywhere from roughly 170 to 190, and for some of us it falls further out still. That's a window of 20 beats or more, and every zone you build from the wrong end of it is out.

That matters more than it sounds. If your calculated max is wrong, every "zone" built from it is wrong too. You'd be training to a number that was never really yours. A watch telling you that 148bpm is "Zone 2" isn't giving you more precision than your own body. It just feels like it is.

The talk test skips the guesswork entirely. Run at a pace where you can hold a proper conversation (string full sentences together without gasping out single words) and you're training at genuine aerobic effort, full stop. No formula, no watch, no guessed number required.

That's why "run by feel" isn't a shrug. It's the more accurate method, not the fallback one.

If you'd still like a starting number, use the standard formula of 220 minus your age, knowing it's probably off by a few beats, and let feel overrule it. By all means, monitor your heart rate during your runs, but without accurate readings for your maximum heart rate I would not stick to prescribed heart rate zones. Run at a comfortable pace and your heart will most likely be in the right zone!

How to Use the Talk Test in a Run-Walk Session

Two runners in yellow and teal jackets pass a walled desert structure at sunrise, beside a shallow puddle.
"Run by feel" is only useful if you know what the feel should be. Here's how I'd apply it, interval by interval.

During each run interval, try reciting the day's plan out loud ("four minutes running, one minute walking, six rounds") without stopping for breath halfway through. If you can say a full sentence comfortably, you're at the right effort. If you're gasping, slow down or walk. No debate.

If you like numbers, think of easy running as 3–4 out of 10 on the rate of perceived exertion (RPE) scale, where 1 is very easy and 10 is all-out. You should finish a run interval feeling you could have done more. Run slower than feels necessary at first. Almost every beginner I coach starts too fast.

Make your walk intervals properly easy too. They aren't a chance to power-walk. They're there so your heart rate and breathing settle before the next run. If you're still puffing when the next run interval starts, extend the walk by 20 or 30 seconds.

One more reason to trust the talk test over a wrist reading: watch sensors can be unreliable in the first few minutes of a run, and in cold weather. Your breathing doesn't have that problem.

Get this routine right first. Three sessions a week, and a consolidation week every 3–4 weeks where you repeat a stage rather than moving up. That consistency does far more for you than any gadget.

When It's Worth Adding a Heart Rate Monitor

A heart rate monitor isn't useless. It just isn't the beginner tool it's often marketed as.

Once you've worked through a structured walk-run program and you're running continuously, no more alternating walk and run intervals, a monitor starts earning its place. At that point it's useful for two things: keeping your easy days easy, and confirming your hard days are actually hard.

Give it a few weeks of continuous running first. Wear it on your easy runs and just look at where your heart rate settles at a comfortable, conversational pace. That's your own easy-run number, and it will drift lower as your fitness builds. That's the first useful thing a monitor tells a new runner. Don't chase it, just notice it. A chest strap reads more accurately than a wrist sensor, so if you're buying one for this purpose, that's where I'd spend the money.

Before you set any zones from it, get a proper reading on your max heart rate, a field test or a lab test, rather than leaning on the age formula. Get an accurate max heart rate reading first, then build your zones from that real number. Zones built on a guess are still a guess, however good the watch is.

For everything else on choosing, wearing, and training with one, see the full guide to heart rate monitor training.

How to Find Your Real Max Heart Rate When You're Ready

Not yet, and if the test Kathryn describes sounds like more than you can face today, leave it. Wait until you've finished a beginners program, you're running non-stop and feeling healthy. And if you have any heart or health concern, check with your doctor before you try a hard effort like this.

When you're ready, here's the field test I'd recommend:
  1. Warm up with 15 minutes of easy running.
  2. Run 3 minutes hard but evenly paced: don't sprint off and fade.
  3. Rest 3 minutes, jogging or walking easily.
  4. Repeat the hard effort, and for the final 2–3 minutes go all-out.
  5. Note the highest number you see.
Do it on a flat track or road, so hills don't skew the result. Wear a chest strap if you can: wrist sensors can lag behind a fast-rising heart rate and under-read your peak. That highest number is your working max. Build your zones from it.

Is It Normal for a Run-Walk Session to Feel Hard?

Dark silhouette of a person crouching on a paved surface at sunset, with a glowing sky and trees on the horizon
Yes, and one tough session doesn't mean anything's wrong.

Kathryn, it's okay if your run feels a little bit like a struggle. You're pushing yourself to new boundaries, so it's only natural that it isn't all easy.

You get good and bad days as well. I sometimes do my long run, come home and feel like I could have gone for twice the distance. And sometimes I do an easy short run and can't push myself forward. Sleep, fueling, stress at work, and how recovered you are all move the needle. That's normal, not a sign your program is wrong for you.

One bad session isn't a red flag. A whole week where every single run feels unusually hard is. That's your cue to repeat the week, or step back one stage, rather than grinding through it.

Not every heart-rate concern is about needing a monitor in the first place. If you're worried your heart rate reads too high instead?, I cover that separately.

My advice to you: leave the watch's numbers alone for now, run slowly, and enjoy each walk-run session as it comes. Listen to your body, and the fitness builds on its own.

All the best,
Dom

Some Other Pages You May Like


Max Heart Rate Heart Rate Zone Training for Your First 10K or Half Marathon What Is A Normal Heart Rate When Running? Heart Rate Zones for More Experienced Runners Tempo Pace by Age and Fitness Level Running Tips Easy Run Pace and Effort Beginner Running Tips


Home > Running Training > Heart Rate Training for Runners > Do Beginners Need a Heart Rate Monitor?

About the author

Dominique de Rooij

Dominique de Rooij (Dom)

Advanced Running Coach certified by Athletics Australia with 20 years of writing about running and over a decade coaching runners, from first races to marathons. Dom created PlanMyRace, a training plan generator for any race from 1500m to the marathon. Now over 50, Dom still loves trail running, parkrun, and the coffee after.



Now Live · PlanMyRace by Best Running Tips

Stop Guessing.
Train for Your Best Race.

PlanMyRace builds a personalized, week-by-week training plan for any race from 1500m to the marathon, around your race date, your current fitness and the week you actually have.

Get My Free Plan →

No credit card needed. Your full first week is free.


What's New?

  1. Cut 90 Seconds Off Your 1.5 Mile Run for the Army Test

    Cutting 90 seconds off a 1.5 mile run in 3-4 weeks for the Army test: Dom breaks down realistic pacing to reduce 10:32 toward sub-9:00 for Paras selection.

    Read more

  2. Training for a 1.5 Mile Run - How to Qualify For Your Test

    Coach Dom's 3-step plan for 1.5 mile run training: build aerobic base, add strides, then tempo and pace work to hit your test time.

    Read more

  3. Improve Your 1.5 Mile Running Time to 10:30: Shin Splints

    From 12:59 to 10:30 for 1.5 miles: Coach Dom's shin-splint fix and training plan to improve your running time in 2-3 months.

    Read more


More New Posts →