Heel Strike or Ball of the Foot?

[?] Subscribe To This Site

Heel Strike or Ball of the Foot?

by Neil
(Birmingham (UK ))

Hello again !
So many questions, hope your not too busy.
When I first started running in February, I remember reading that heel striking was good form, and this allowed your foot to roll naturally etc etc.. however, I have since read articles contradicting this advise suggesting that a mid foot / ball of foot landing sends less reaction to the upper body preventing injury.

I had tried to modify my form to heel strike and now I read this.... confused ? ! ?

Please help.

Regards
Neil (UK)

Answer by Dominique:

Hi Neil,
Thx for your running training question. I should start charging for this service (no worries, I won't)...
It's a great debate isn't: what is better, ball of the foot landing or heel strike?
Another good one is about whether cross-training is good for you or not. Everyone seems to have an opinion.

I am a "heel striker" as well, as many other runners are. Some others land on the ball of the foot and they feel that that comes naturally to them.

Heel striking is the more traditional running form.
In the last few years the Pose Technique, the technique which uses ball of foot landing, has been getting quite some publicity.

There are some interesting books out on the Pose Technique, e.g. the Pose Method of Running and the Pose Method of Running Companion Drill Book. They teach you about why this type of running would be better and the types of exercises you can do to learn this technique.

I do not have sufficient knowledge about running form, sports physiology etc to tell you to use the one method or the other.
The truth is probably in the middle.
Do what makes you feel best, do what comes naturally to you and that is probably the right running technique for you.

Hope this helps.
Looking forward to your next question!
Cheers,
Dominique

Comments for
Heel Strike or Ball of the Foot?

Click here to add your own comments

Interesting Point of View...
by: Dominique (webmaster)

Hi I. Viola,
I liked your post very much.
Sounds like you have given the issue some good thought.

Barefoot running has become really popular, especially since Born to Run was published and became a bit of a bestseller. The writer provides quite a compelling argument for barefoot running, but I agree, running surfaces today are not what they used to be thousands of years ago.

The jury is still out on what is right and what is wrong I guess.
I like the current line of Newton running shoes, see Newton Running Shoes for Men and Newton Running Shoes for Women.

Through their design, these shoes make you gravitate towards ball-of-the-foot running, however still with providing you the protection of running shoes.

The Vibram Five Fingers, basically a "glove for your feet" are a real hit and I have seen people run with them in street races. They look cool, but don't offer a hell of a lot of protection it seems. I wonder about the longer term effects on people's feet or about incidents with sharp objects etc.

Then again, the whole argument for barefoot running is that our feet are strong enough themselves and don't need any protection.

Tough, tough, tough, I will see if I can get in contact with the Newton running company and throw some questions their way regarding this issue, I find it very interesting. When/if I get some answers, I will publish it in my Best Running Tips Newsletter.

Cheers,
Dominique (webmaster)

X Close Editor

Rating

Submitted by: Dominique (webmaster)

Title

Comment
Hi I. Viola, I liked your post very much. Sounds like you have given the issue some good thought. Barefoot running has become really popular, especially since <a href="http://www.best-running-gear.com/born-to-run.shtml">Born to Run</a> was published and became a bit of a bestseller. The writer provides quite a compelling argument for barefoot running, but I agree, running surfaces today are not what they used to be thousands of years ago. The jury is still out on what is right and what is wrong I guess. I like the current line of Newton running shoes, see <a href="http://www.best-running-tips.com/newton-running-shoes-for-men.html">Newton Running Shoes for Men</a> and <a href="http://www.best-running-tips.com/newton-running-shoes-for-women.html">Newton Running Shoes for Women</a>. Through their design, these shoes make you gravitate towards ball-of-the-foot running, however still with providing you the protection of running shoes. The Vibram Five Fingers, basically a "glove for your feet" are a real hit and I have seen people run with them in street races. They look cool, but don't offer a hell of a lot of protection it seems. I wonder about the longer term effects on people's feet or about incidents with sharp objects etc. Then again, the whole argument for barefoot running is that our feet are strong enough themselves and don't need any protection. Tough, tough, tough, I will see if I can get in contact with the Newton running company and throw some questions their way regarding this issue, I find it very interesting. When/if I get some answers, I will publish it in my <a href="http://www.best-running-tips.com/newsletter.html">Best Running Tips Newsletter</a>. Cheers, Dominique (webmaster)

Cancel Delete Delete & Ban

throbber Updating Comments page...

"Natural" running on "unnatural" surfaces?
by: I. Viola

I understand the argument that humans are natural runners, and that running shoes are a modern invention. But so is pavement. I would think that running barefoot on bare ground, grass, or sand might be the ideal, but running on asphalt or cement without some added shock absorber doesn't make any sense to me. What is the current thought on this?

The argument that the running shoe industry is just in place to hose us is an argument that could be made for all non-essential consumer goods. I would urge us to take pause and consider which sporting equipment (paddles, life preservers, sails for boats, balls for games, visors and eye protection for various sports, bicycles, wetsuits, baseball bats, gloves, rock climbing equipment, helmets, pick your sport and the list goes on...) may give us a more efficient, safer, or more enjoyable way to exercise and move our bodies than the "natural" forms we were born with.

I would also argue that technological innovations are "natural" responses to our desire to expand our ability to move over terrain, through the water, and against or with the wind. I agree that there is a lot of junk out there, and plenty of folks just trying to make a buck, but we shouldn't throw the good equipment/accessories out with the bad.

Don't Heelstrike (please)
by: Anonymous

Actually, a midfoot/forefoot strike is the way humans are designed to run. If you take off your shoes and go for a run you will find it impossible to heelstrike. if you use your legs and feet the way they were designed they will reduce the force of the impacts far more effectively than any shoe that has ever been designed. Again, humans are natural runners, and the notion that we must by expensive shoes in order to run has been propagated by shoe companies to sell more shoes.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Running Training Helpline

Running to Lose Weight?

Do you have 10 pounds that you just want to get rid of so that you can fit into that bathing suit that you are dying to wear?

Are you looking for a way to jump start a diet so that you can get to the weight that is best for you?

Are you tired of promises from pills and potions that promise to take that weight off easily but do not work?

Are you sick of seeing ads to help you take off weight if only you pay a small fortune for a membership in some club, special food or some drug?

If so, then CLICK HERE for the no-nonsense weight loss solution that actually works.

Check out The 100 Day Marathon Plan

100 Day Marathon Plan from Marius Bakken presents a welcome fresh training approach to marathon running that has proven to be very effective. It's the best marathon training program available today.

Marius has competed in the Olympics and has trained with world-class athletes from Italy and Kenya. He has learnt from these runners and has made those training methods applicable to marathon training programs for normal people like ourselves. This marathon plan prepares you well for a marathon by first focusing on 5k and 10k training. Only when you are ready Marius moves on to marathon training.

Want to get ready for a marathon within 100 days?
Then you need to give the 100 Day Marathon Plan a try.

Click here for more information about the 100 Day Marathon Plan.